x

How do you choose bike insurance?
 

How do you choose bike insurance?

It started with a simple question in the Wanderers’ WhatsApp group:

“Recommendations please for bike insurance given a bike worthy of more than just home and contents, will be used for racing (TTs) and I’m a British Cycling member?”

As usual, Wanderers were quick to help. Yellow Jersey, Bikmo, Pedal Cover, Velosure and Laka all received recommendations, mostly from members who had actually used them.

But which is best?

As it happens, I was wondering much the same thing. I’ve been insured with Laka for several years and have had three claims – two ordinary cycling tumbles and one racing incident. On each occasion, they’ve been excellent: knowledgeable, straightforward and no quibbling over the claim.

The problem is the price. My monthly payment had risen to around £80 for just one bike, although I’ve since reduced the cover and my latest bill was £65.39. That prompted me to see what else was available.

What started as a quick price comparison turned into something rather more intricate.

First, work out what you actually need

My requirements aren’t especially unusual for a club cyclist. I have three bikes I regularly ride: a Scott Foil, a Specialized Tarmac and a Specialized Chisel mountain bike, worth around £9,750 between them, including a power meter.

I compete in time trials, ride the occasional sportive and take a bike to Europe a couple of times a year. I also want my Garmin and some cycling kit covered.

That immediately exposed one of the problems with comparing bike insurance: apparently similar policies aren’t necessarily covering the same things.

Take racing. Laka includes time trials within its normal event cover because they don’t require the type of racing licence used for road racing. Bikmo Protect also includes TTs. Yellow Jersey, however, confirmed that I’d need its top-level – much more expensive – Ultimate policy.

If you’re a Wanderer like me who only competes in local TTs, that’s quite an important distinction.

Don’t just compare the headline price

Bikmo initially looked like the runaway winner.

Through British Cycling, I was quoted £37.75 a month, or £453 a year, for all three bikes. It included theft, accidental damage, 365-day worldwide cover, TTs and sportives, new-for-old replacement and £1,950 of combined clothing, headgear and accessory cover.

Yellow Jersey Ultimate came in at £737 a year, without clothing or helmet cover.

Then came the catch.

I’d made three claims in the previous five years. Bikmo’s online quotation hadn’t asked about them, but when I queried this before buying, they confirmed that their underwriting criteria allow no more than two theft or damage claims in five years.

They declined to insure me ☹️ (the price of being honest).

One of my claims falls outside that five-year window at the end of this year, so I’ll be knocking on their door again. But it demonstrated that a great quote isn’t much use until you know you’re eligible for it.

Look at the excess too

Velosure provided another useful lesson.

Because of my claims history, they referred my application to their underwriters, but good news – they accepted! They subsequently offered their Performance cover for £577.59 a year.

That covers all three bikes, time trials and other events, worldwide use and £1,000 of accessories, along with benefits including cycle rescue, personal accident and replacement cycle hire.

The price looks good, but the excess deserves attention.

For accidental damage, it’s 10% of the bike’s value, with a minimum of £100 and maximum of £400. So crashing my £6,200 Scott would mean a £400 excess. The equivalent excess on my £1,900 Tarmac would be £190.

Laka, by comparison, has no bike-claim excess.

That’s worth putting a value on, particularly if have a calamitous history like mine.

Read the bits that aren’t about the bike

The exercise uncovered plenty of other differences.

How secure does a bike have to be in your garage? What lock must you use when stopping at a café? Are accessories covered independently or only if they’re damaged in the same incident as the bike? Is your bike covered while an airline has it? What happens to your helmet and clothing after a crash?

Even apparently attractive extras can have limitations. Velosure’s cycle-rescue policy, for example, excludes incidents while the bike is being used for racing or speed/endurance tests.

None of these necessarily makes a policy good or bad. They simply reinforce the importance of matching the cover to how you actually ride.

Bike insurance at a glance

There are too many variables to make a meaningful comparison of premiums – your postcode, bike values, claims history and the cover you choose can all change the price. But we can compare some of the features that might matter to a typical club cyclist.

← Swipe to compare insurers →

Laka Complete Bikmo Yellow Jersey Ultimate Velosure Performance Pedal Cover
Accidental damage ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Time trials ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓* ✓*
Road/crit racing Add-on Optional/appropriate racing cover ✓ ✓* ✓*
Overseas bike cover Add-on, up to 120 days Worldwide, 365 days Worldwide, trips up to 120 days ✓* Optional/policy dependent
Typical bike excess £0 £40 under £400; normally 10% above 10%, capped at £100 10% accidental damage, max £400 Policy dependent
Kit/accessories ✓ ✓ – limits linked to bike value £250 accessories; clothing/helmet optional ✓* ✓
Multi-bike saving 50% additional bikes 50% lower-value additional bikes 60% additional bikes Multi-bike pricing Bikes included within home/cycle policy
Public liability ✓ Available depending on policy £2m ✓* ✓
Policy style Flexible monthly/collective Specialist bike insurance Specialist bike insurance Specialist bike insurance Home insurance designed for cyclists

*Cover can depend on the individual policy, options selected and/or what is shown on the policy schedule. This is a high-level comparison based on insurers’ published information and policy documents checked in September 2026. Terms can change, so always check the current policy wording and your own schedule before buying.

So which bike insurance is best?

I’ve made my choice, but it doesn’t mean it’s the right choice for everyone.

Laka remains expensive, but I’ve tested its claims service three times and it has been excellent. Bikmo looks particularly attractive for my needs but won’t insure me until an old claim drops off my five-year history. Pedal Cover takes a different approach by combining cycling and home insurance, which I might investigate when my home policy next comes up for renewal. Velosure has proved a credible and cheaper alternative for my requirements – and they’ve got the deal.

And that’s probably the most useful conclusion from the exercise.

There isn’t a universally “best” bike insurer.

Before getting quotes, decide what matters to you: the bikes and equipment you need to insure, whether you race, whether that racing includes time trials, where you travel, what excess you’re prepared to accept and what protection you already have through British Cycling or your home insurance.

Then compare the policies on that basis.

The cheapest quote may not provide the cover you need – and, as I discovered, it may not even be a quote you’re eligible to accept.

 

September 21, 2026 Categories: Opinion